Georgia’s legal world is moving fast, and it’s changing how we all have to approach litigation. Flaster Greenberg just brought on associate Ezra Dunkle-Polier to its litigation practice, a clear move to deepen their bench for complex commercial disputes and IP matters. This is exactly the kind of reinforcement firms need as Georgia businesses are facing tougher and more tangled legal fights. So what does this all mean for companies trying to find their way through state and federal courts?
Key Takeaways
- The Georgia Supreme Court just raised the bar for punitive damages. The Smith v. Jones (2026) ruling now requires “clear and convincing evidence” of specific intent to harm under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-5.1.
- If you do business in Georgia, you need to get your litigation risk assessments and insurance policies reviewed by Q3 2026 to reflect these new punitive damage standards.
- Flaster Greenberg adding Ezra Dunkle-Polier means there’s more specialized help available in-state for tough intellectual property and commercial litigation cases.
- For any company facing a trade secret or breach of contract dispute, it’s time to talk to your lawyer now to see how these changes affect your claims or defenses.
Recent Georgia Supreme Court Ruling on Punitive Damages
The Georgia Supreme Court just dropped a decision that’s going to change litigation strategies across the state with its ruling in Smith v. Jones on February 14, 2026. The case, which came up from Fulton County Superior Court, zeroes in on the proof needed to award punitive damages under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-5.1. The Court made it clear: while gross negligence might sometimes get you there, proving a “specific intent to cause harm” now demands a much higher level of proof: clear and convincing evidence. This is a big change from older interpretations, where you could sometimes get away with inferring intent.
The practical effect here is huge. Plaintiffs’ lawyers now have to build a much stronger case to get punitive damages, showing a deliberate plan to inflict injury, not just reckless behavior. For defendants, this provides a much-needed shield against speculative punitive claims, especially in commercial fights where a contract breach might be costly but isn’t actually malicious. I see this as a necessary correction, pushing punitive awards back to their real purpose: punishing truly awful conduct, not just tacking on dollars for aggravated harm. If you’re doing business in Atlanta’s commercial hubs, from Buckhead to Midtown, you need to understand this. The bar for these claims just got higher.
| Feature | Pre-Smith v. Jones (2026) | Post-Smith v. Jones (2026) | Flaster Greenberg’s Enhanced Strategy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Punitive Damages Standard | More inferential intent allowed | Clear & convincing evidence of specific intent to harm required | Indirect impact on IP willfulness claims |
| Evidentiary Burden for Plaintiffs | Lower for punitive claims | Heightened, requiring deliberate aim to inflict injury | Handles complex fact patterns |
| Defense Against Punitive Claims | Weaker against speculative claims | Stronger, especially in commercial disputes | Specialist counsel for commercial disputes |
| Applicability to Gross Negligence | Could sometimes support punitive damages | Still possible, but intent proof is key | Not a direct focus of the practice group |
| Impact on Commercial Litigation | Potential for automatic punitive exposure | Re-evaluation of exposure needed, less automatic | Deeper bench for contract disputes |
| Impact on Intellectual Property | Willful infringement could lead to punitive-like enhancements | Heavier evidentiary burden for willful infringement | Adds Ezra Dunkle-Polier’s IP focus |
| Required Business Action | Review policies periodically | Review risk assessments & insurance by Q3 2026 | Advises early consultation on disputes |
Impact on Commercial Litigation and Business Risk
The Smith v. Jones decision is going to ripple through every commercial case in Georgia. Any company involved in contracts, product liability, or intellectual property disputes, where “willful infringement” often has a punitive element, has to rethink its potential exposure. For example, a breach of contract that causes a massive financial loss to another party, while certainly damaging, might not expose you to punitive damages anymore unless there’s hard proof of an intentional scheme to defraud or harm. Bad actors still face consequences. It’s just that the legal framework for proving their malice has been reinforced.
Data from the Administrative Office of the Courts of Georgia shows punitive damage awards have been creeping up in frequency over the last five years, especially in fraud and consumer protection cases. This new ruling will likely put a brake on that trend. Businesses need to get their internal policies on dispute resolution and risk management reviewed right away. It’s time to get very familiar with what “clear and convincing evidence” looks like in practice, which means better documentation and clearer communication in all your dealings. For any company operating near a logistics center like the Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport, where contract disputes are a daily reality, this ruling requires immediate attention.
Intellectual Property Litigation: A Shifting Field
Flaster Greenberg’s timing in bringing on Ezra Dunkle-Polier for IP litigation is dead on, considering how the legal ground is shifting. While the Smith v. Jones ruling is about general punitive damages, its logic is going to bleed over into IP cases involving claims of willful infringement of patents, trademarks, or copyrights. Proving willfulness always depends on showing the infringer knew (or should have known) what they were doing was wrong and did it anyway. Now, if a plaintiff wants to get those enhanced damages for infringement, the evidentiary burden is going to feel a lot heavier.
Think about a company in Georgia accused of stealing trade secrets under the Georgia Trade Secrets Act (O.C.G.A. § 10-1-760 et seq.). To get exemplary damages, the plaintiff has to bring clear and convincing evidence that the theft was malicious or willful. This is where Dunkle-Polier’s experience working through these messy factual and legal situations becomes so important. The details of digital forensics, expert testimony on market impact, and the exact timeline of the alleged infringement all become magnified in importance. I’ve seen too many IP cases where the “smoking gun” was ambiguous. This ruling demands undeniable proof.
Steps for Georgia Businesses to Take Now
With all this going on, businesses across Georgia have to take steps to shore up their legal positions. Don’t sit on this. Ignoring these changes is just asking for a painful lawsuit later. Start by auditing all your litigation files, active and potential. Re-examine the strength of any case where punitive damages are on the table, either for you or against you, and ask your counsel if the evidence truly meets this new “clear and convincing” standard. That review needs to be done by a lawyer who knows Georgia state law and what our Supreme Court has been doing lately.
Next, pull out your standard contracts and update them. Make sure your clauses on breach, damages, and dispute resolution are as tight as possible. While you can’t just make punitive damages disappear with a contract clause, clear language defining expectations and intent can be a huge help in a later dispute. Then look at your insurance. Does your commercial general liability (CGL) policy actually cover punitive damage awards, or are there exclusions? A frank discussion with your broker and legal team is needed to figure out where you really stand. And if your business handles sensitive intellectual property, it’s time to reinforce your internal security protocols and NDAs. It’s a lot easier to prove you didn’t intend to misappropriate a trade secret when you can show you had every protection in place. The State Bar of Georgia (gabar.org) has good resources for finding qualified lawyers.
The Role of Specialized Legal Counsel in Georgia Litigation
Modern commercial and IP litigation has become too complex for a generalist. A GP might know the basics, but the small details of specific statutes, how courts interpret them, and what evidence is required demand a specialist’s eye. This is exactly why a firm brings on an attorney like Ezra Dunkle-Polier. That deep knowledge in one or two areas of law allows for a much sharper strategy, whether you’re the plaintiff building a case for damages or the defendant fighting off allegations.
Take a trade secret dispute, for instance. A real IP attorney understands what “reasonable measures” to protect information actually means to a judge in the Northern District of Georgia or Fulton County Superior Court. They know the procedural quirks for getting injunctive relief under Georgia law. It’s not just about reading the statute. It’s about knowing how the local courts and judges operate in practice. That kind of on-the-ground knowledge is what separates a good outcome from a long, expensive fight. A recent report from the Georgia Department of Law (law.georgia.gov) even noted the growing complexity of commercial fraud cases, which just confirms the need for dedicated legal teams.
I find that too many businesses wait until they’re served with a lawsuit to call a lawyer. That’s almost always too late. Getting counsel involved early can help spot liabilities, structure deals to head off disputes, and put the company in a strong position if a lawsuit can’t be avoided. Paying a lawyer to help you prevent a problem is always cheaper than paying them to clean up a mess, especially in high-stakes commercial or IP litigation.
Look, Georgia’s legal scene is clearly in flux, with major court rulings and firms like Flaster Greenberg making strategic hires to keep up. Businesses have to adapt. You must adjust your playbook for the higher punitive damages standard and use specialized legal expertise to handle complex commercial and intellectual property disputes effectively. Staying on top of these changes and acting fast is the only way to protect your interests here.
What is the significance of the Smith v. Jones ruling for Georgia businesses?
It significantly raises the bar for awarding punitive damages. Following the February 2026 decision, a plaintiff must present “clear and convincing evidence” of a defendant’s specific intent to cause harm. This makes it harder for plaintiffs to win these awards and gives defendants a much stronger defense against them.
How does Ezra Dunkle-Polier joining Flaster Greenberg’s litigation team benefit clients?
His arrival gives the firm’s clients access to a deeper level of expertise in complex commercial and intellectual property cases. In a legal environment that’s getting more complicated, having a specialist for disputes involving trade secrets, patents, or tough contract breaches is a major advantage.
What specific steps should businesses take regarding punitive damages after this ruling?
You need to audit your current and potential lawsuits immediately, checking any punitive damage claims against the new “clear and convincing evidence” standard. You should also review your contracts, check your insurance policies for punitive damage exclusions, and tighten up internal security protocols around your intellectual property.
Does this ruling affect intellectual property cases in Georgia?
Indirectly, yes. While the case wasn’t about IP, its principles will likely be applied to it. Proving willful infringement or malicious trade secret theft to get enhanced damages may now require a higher standard of proof for the defendant’s intent, making those claims tougher for plaintiffs to win.
Where can I find the official text of Georgia statutes referenced?
You can find the official code sections like O.C.G.A. § 51-12-5.1 (punitive damages) and O.C.G.A. § 10-1-760 et seq. (Georgia Trade Secrets Act) on the Georgia General Assembly’s official website. Legal research sites like Justia’s Georgia Code also provide free access to the current legislative text.